5 Strikes: New challenges for old warhorses | ABF, DOTD, MGNS, TAM

Richard Beddard looks at four companies on his radar: ABF divorces and exits 5 Strikes, dotdigital is locked in a competitive dogfight, Morgan Sindall underestimates itself again, and Tatton’s price advantage continues to diminish.

5 Strikes

Since my last update, five companies have passed my minimum quality filter.

Name TIDM Prev AR Strikes # Strikes
SNWS Smiths News 4/11/26 ? Holdings – Debt – Growth 2
ABF Associated British Foods 3/11/26 ? Holdings – Growth – ROCE 2
DOTD Dotdigital 3/11/26 – Holdings – Acquisitions 2
TUNE Focusrite 3/11/26 – Holdings – Growth – ROCE 3
GATC Gattaca 3/11/26 – CROCI – Growth – ROCE 3
Click here for our 5 Strikes explainer 11/11/2026

On closer inspection of their director’s holdings and financial track records, I awarded three of them less than three strikes. Uncomplicated histories are easier to understand, which is why I feel competent enough to analyse them.

Smiths News has yet to publish its annual report on its website, so in addition to examining Associated British Foods and dotdigital, I am catching up with a couple of other companies of interest.

Associated British Foods [? Holdings – Growth – ROCE]

The last ever ABF annual report has dropped. In December, the 60 year old conglomerate splits into two businesses: Primark and AB Foods. Primark is the budget retail chain. AB Foods remains a conglomerate. It houses the group’s food, ingredients, sugar and agri-food businesses.

Both companies are well established and earn in excess of £1billion in turnover. As separate entities, they will likely remain in the FTSE 100.

Source: ABF annual report

However they will not pass my minimum quality filter next year because they will have very short track records as listed entities. The minimum quality filter requires eight.

Dotdigital [- Holdings – Acquisitions]

A principal objection to investing in Dotdigital is its acquisition spending, which exceeded free-cash flow by some margin in two of the last three years:

Although the company has spent more than it has earned in cash terms, dotdigital had saved up a lot of cash in the 2010s and early 2020s. It drew on that cash to acquire other businesses, rather than borrow or raise money from shareholders.

Since dotdigital still has a cash surplus, and is still generating positive cash flow, we can say with some confidence that the spending spree has not put its finances in jeopardy.

Negative net borrowing in the chart below is the same thing as positive net cash. Dotdigital’s cash pile has shrunk, but it still has one.

My concern is that the acquisitions have changed the nature of the business, and despite the injection of turnover, growth has slowed somewhat:

This implies the pre-existing business is growing much more slowly than it was, or contracting.

Originally, dotdigital was a one product company called dotmailer. Dotmailer was email marketing software. By the time I took my first look at the company in 2018, it was already becoming dotdigital. The name change reflected its evolution into a “marketing automation platform”.

Essentially, it was a cloud-based software platform that connected organisations’ data with dotmailer to generate email marketing campaigns. Already it was incorporating other channels, principally SMS.

This year’s annual report reveals dotdigital has added many more channels to the platform, which include email, web, SMS, WhatsApp, chat, push, and social ads.

Two of its recent acquisitions extend the platform further. Social Snowball enables companies to run referral programmes to convert customers into influencers. Alia enables pop-up interactions with customers.

I think dotdigital must add these capabilities to stay relevant as digital marketing evolves, and channels and competitors proliferate.

The pace of change is accelerating due to the emergence native AI competitors and the introduction of AI in established platforms (dotdigital has embraced AI too):

Source: Principal risks and uncertainties, 2026 annual report

And acquiring more capabilities exposes dotdigital to even more competition:

Source: Principal risks and uncertainties, 2026 annual report

Maybe dotdigital’s combination of capabilities is unusual enough for it to win more customers than it loses to the competition. But the results do not show it yet, and the challenge seems daunting.

Companies of interest

Morgan Sindall [No strikes (23 June 2026)]

When I awarded Morgan Sindall no strikes last June, I noted the extraordinary performance of its Fit Out division, which trades as Overbury and Morgan Lovell and builds office interiors.

Fit Out had more than doubled revenue and quadrupled profit since 2019, contributing 35% of the group’s total revenue and 60% of its profit.

Essentially, Morgan Sindall is funneling profit from Fit Out and the company’s smaller construction and infrastructure businesses, into its as yet less profitable property development businesses.

Fit Out’s growth is extraordinary in its own terms, but also because Morgan Sindall has repeatedly guided us to expect less. It has a medium-term target of £80m – £100m adjusted operating profit. In the annual report, Fit Out delivered £140m, but the company reiterated the division’s downbeat prospects.

Twice since, though, Morgan Sindall has lifted our expectations. The second time, in a trading update earlier this month, it gave us a number: £140m, the same as last year. Fit-Out refuses to stoop to management’s low expectations.

Assuming Fit Out will eventually succumb to the target makes the investment tricky to evaluate. Construction and Infrastructure are less profitable businesses but growing. Partnership Housing and Mixed Use Partnerships, the property development businesses, require more capital and are hidebound by weak demand and start up costs.

Tatton Asset Management [No strikes (15 July]]

Tatton is another company with no strikes to its name. In July I reported that it is the biggest Model Portfolio Service (MPS) for Independent Financial Advisers (IFAs).

Essentially, financial advisers outsource investment management to MPSs so they can focus on financial planning and customer relationships. Tatton manages the investments through third party investment platforms.

MPSs have grown very strongly over the last decade. Needless to say, because it has no strikes in its historical record, Tatton has been highly profitable and cash generative too.

In results for the half-year to September published last week, Tatton reported that MPS charges have dropped to about 16 basis points (0.16% of assets under management) across the industry, compared to 17 basis points at the end of 2025. It says it has long forecast charges will settle at 15 bps, which is what it has charged since launch in 2012.

Apparently Tatton’s price advantage is diminishing, which made me wonder what else makes Tatton special.

Tatton says its secret sauce is that it works exclusively with IFA’s*, which means “we champion advisers rather than compete with them”.

Other MPSs tend to be part of broader financial groups like wealth managers and investment platforms. AJ Bell is perhaps the example with most name recognition. Quilter and Brooks Macdonald are two listed wealth managers that provide MPSs.

*Tatton kind of competes against itself at one stage removed. Tatton has an investment in Absolute Financial Management, a private equity backed IFA consolidator.

All the 0’s, 1’s and 2’s

Currently, 220 shares pass my minimum quality filter. I have awarded less than three strikes to 104. Thirteen have achieved no strikes, 35 have 1 strike, and 56 have two strikes.

The links in the table below go to articles in which I discuss these shares.

CER Cerillion 24/11/25 0 >
PRV Porvair 9/2/26 ? Holdings 0 >
MGNS Morgan Sindall 25/2/26 0 >
HWDN Howden Joinery 26/2/26 ? Holdings 0 >
FOUR 4imprint 11/3/26 ? Holdings 0 >
NICL Nichols 11/3/26 0 >
CCC Computacenter 12/3/26 0 >
QTX Quartix 25/3/26 ? ROCE 0 >
KEYS Keystone Law 29/4/26 0 >
KNOS Kainos 18/5/26 ? Growth 0 >
CWK Cranswick 19/5/26 ? Growth 0 >
AUTO Autotrader 21/5/26 0 >
TAM Tatton Asset Management 16/6/26 0 >
IPX IMPAX Asset Management 1/12/25 – Growth 1
BOWL Hollywood Bowl 16/12/25 – Debt 1 >
RMV Rightmove 27/2/26 – Holdings 1
IMI IMI 6/3/26 ? Holdings – Debt ? Growth 1
CKN Clarkson 9/3/26 ? Growth – ROCE 1
ROR Rotork 10/3/26 – Holdings ? Growth 1
HILS Hill & Smith 11/3/26 – Holdings ? Acquisitions 1
ALFA Alfa Financial Software 12/3/26 – Growth 1 >
MAB1 Mortgage Advice Bureau 17/3/26 – Shares 1
SAG Science 17/3/26 ? Growth 1
FDM FDM Group 18/3/26 – Growth 1 >
MEGP Me Group 23/3/26 – Growth ? ROCE 1 >
GAMA Gamma Communications 24/3/26 ? Acquisitions – Holdings 1 >
NXT Next 26/3/26 – Debt 1
BAG Barr (AG) 31/3/26 ? Acquisitions ? Growth 1
ELCO Eleco 28/4/26 – Holdings ? Growth 1
W7L Warpaint London 29/4/26 – Shares ? Growth 1
LSC London Security 8/5/26 – Holdings 1
BMY Bloomsbury Publishing 20/5/26 – Growth 1 >
PETS Pets at Home 27/5/26 – Holdings ? Growth 1
HLMA Halma 11/6/26 ? Holdings ? Acquisitions 1
XPS XPS Pensions 18/6/26 ? Holdings ? Debt 1
CBOX Cake Box 30/6/26 ? Acquisitions – Debt 1 >
LTHM Latham (James) 2/7/26 – CROCI ? Growth 1 >
JET2 Jet2 8/7/26 ? Holdings ? CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 1 >
GAW Games Workshop 28/7/26 ? Holdings 1
CFX Colefax 31/7/26 ? Growth 1 >
ASHM Ashmore 7/9/26 ? CROCI – Growth 1 >
DNLM Dunelm 8/9/26 – Debt 1 >
ARC Arcontech 14/9/26 – Growth 1 >
RSW Renishaw 23/9/26 – CROCI 1 >
TFW Thorpe (F W) 1/10/26 – Growth 1 >
JHD James Halstead 14/10/26 – Growth 1 >
TSTL Tristel 19/10/26 – Holdings 1 >
BVXP Bioventix 26/10/26 – Growth 1 >
SGE Sage 19/11/25 – Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2
TRCS Tracsis 20/11/25 – Holdings – ROCE ? Growth 2 >
RNWH Renew 25/11/25 ? Holdings – Shares 2
RWS RWS 11/12/25 ? Acquisitions – Growth – ROCE 2 >
GDP Goldplat 15/12/25 – Growth ? ROCE 2
IHP IntegraFin 17/12/25 – CROCI 2
RFX Ramsdens 14/1/26 – CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 2 >
STEM SThree 27/1/26 – Holdings – Growth 2
GSK GSK 4/2/26 ? Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2
REL RELX 12/2/26 ? Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2 >
ULVR Unilever 12/2/26 – Debt – Growth 2
IHG InterContinental Hotels 17/2/26 ? Holdings – Debt 2
BA. BAE Systems 18/2/26 ? Holdings ? Acquisitions – Debt ? Growth 2 >
MONY Mony 23/2/26 – Holdings ? Growth 2
CTEC ConvaTec 24/2/26 ? holdings – Debt ? Growth ? ROCE 2 >
HIK Hikma Pharmaceuticals 26/2/26 ? Acquisitions – Debt 2
MACF Macfarlane 26/2/26 – Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2 >
BNZL Bunzl 2/3/26 ? Holdings – Debt – Growth 2 >
DATA GlobalData 2/3/26 ? Acquisitions – Debt ? ROCE 2 >
INCH Inchcape 3/3/26 ? Holdings ? Debt – Growth 2 >
ITRK Intertek 3/3/26 ? Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2
JSG Johnson Service 3/3/26 – Holdings – Debt 2
PAGE Michael Page 5/3/26 – Holdings? CROCI – Debt – Growth – ROCE 2
DOM Domino’s Pizza 10/3/26 – Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2
SPX Spirax 10/3/26 – Holdings – Debt ? Growth 2
BBY Balfour Beatty 11/3/26 – Holdings ? CROCI ? Growth – ROCE 2
SVS Savills 12/3/26 – Holdings – CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 2
YU. Yu 17/3/26 – CROCI ? ROCE 2
CAML Central Asia Metals 19/3/26 – Growth ? ROCE 2
IGG IG Group 19/3/26 – Holdings – Growth 2
EKF EKF Diagnostics 24/3/26 ? CROCI – Growth ? ROCE 2
FEVR Fevertree Drinks 24/3/26 – CROCI – Growth 2
LUCE Luceco 25/3/26 ? Acquisitions – Debt ? Growth ? ROCE 2
JIM Jarvis Securities 30/3/26 – CROCI – Growth 2
ANP Anpario 31/3/26 ? CROCI – Growth ? ROCE 2 >
JDG Judges Scientific 31/3/26 ? Acquisitions – Debt – Growth 2 >
APTD Aptitude Software 8/4/26 – Holdings ? Acquisitions – Growth 2
WINK M Winkworth 15/4/26 – Holdings – Growth 2
CARD Card Factory 28/4/26 – Holdings – Debt 2
IOF Iofina 30/4/26 ? CROCI – ROCE ? Shares 2
ASY Andrews Sykes 12/5/26 – Holdings – Growth 2
QQ. QinetiQ 21/5/26 ? Holdings ? Acquisitions ? Growth – ROCE 2
OXIG Oxford Instruments 9/6/26 – Holdings – Growth 2 >
REC Record 19/6/26 – Holdings – Growth 2
BKG Berkeley Group Holdings (The) 24/6/26 ? CROCI – Growth ? ROCE 2
POLR Polar Capital 1/7/26 ? Holdings – Growth 2
MSI MS International 16/7/26 – CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 2
NTBR Northern Bear 16/7/26 – CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 2
GDWN Goodwin 28/8/26 – CROCI – Growth ? ROCE 2 >
AEO Aeorema Communications 22/9/26 – CROCI ? Growth ? ROCE 2
NET Netcall 7/10/26 – Acquisitions ? ROCE – Shares 2
FAN Volution 8/10/26 ? Holdings – Acquisitions – Borrowings 2
SCT Softcat 14/10/26 – Holdings ? Growth 2
ABF Associated British Foods 3/11/26 ? Holdings – Growth – ROCE 2
DOTD Dotdigital 3/11/26 – Holdings – Acquisitions 2
SNWS Smiths News 4/11/26 ? Holdings – Debt – Growth 2
Click here for our 5 Strikes explainer 11/11/2026

 

Richard Beddard

Contact Richard Beddard by email: richard@beddard.net, web: beddard.net

This article is for educational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell shares or other investments. Do your own research before buying or selling any investment or seek professional financial advice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *