Michael looks at the benefits of a sharper mind and how to cultivate an edge in trading.
The difference between winners and losers is almost always the mindset. And yes, there are lots of other things that go into successful trading, such as knowledge, hard work, and the ability to learn quickly.
But you can give a trader the best tools, the best setups, and the best plan on how to position size and manage risk, and they would still blow it. Humans aren’t designed to be expert traders. Trading isn’t just about numbers, strategies, and technical analysis. Those components are critical to success, but psychology is the key factor that often separates successful traders from those who consistently fail.
I’d argue that trading psychology is one of the most important factors of success. Without the ability to manage your mindset, emotions, and mental state, even the best strategies can lead to catastrophic losses.
When people first enter the world of trading, they tend to focus on learning about charts, patterns, indicators, and fundamental analysis. I know I certainly did. I didn’t read a single book on trading psychology. To me, it seemed a bit of a gimmick. In fact, trading psychology didn’t ever occur to me until I wore my first big loss.
Over time, most traders realise that their own mental and emotional state is the real battleground. Markets are unpredictable, and volatile, and can generate a rollercoaster of emotions like fear, greed, anxiety, and overconfidence. All of these can derail the best of intentions. To put it simply, if you can’t master your mind, you won’t be able to master the market.
This is where trading psychology comes in; having a structured mental approach that keeps you grounded, disciplined, and focused regardless of what the market throws at you.
I had a client this week talk to me about two trades. Unfortunately, a mistake on the first trade led to the second trade being affected. Don’t discount the emotional effect on your performance. If you find this happening then the solution is always to size lower.
Why is trading psychology important?
Markets are driven by human behaviour. The Efficient Market Hypothesis will of course have you believe otherwise. But whether it’s institutional traders, retail investors, or market makers, the actions people take are influenced by their emotions and beliefs. The difficulty lies in staying calm and rational in an environment designed to exploit your emotional weaknesses.
There are several ways in which trading psychology can influence your decisions:
- Fear and panic: When a trade moves against you, the natural human response is fear. This leads to loss aversion under the false belief that you “haven’t lost until you sell”, which is ridiculous. The merchandise is already worth less, you just haven’t crystallised it.
- Greed: When a trade goes well, the desire to be right can take over and have you exit your winners early. The ego is happy but you may watch the trade power higher without you in it.
- Overconfidence: A string of successful trades can make you feel invincible, leading to larger and riskier positions, which can wipe out your account. I’ve done this one too.
- Hesitation: Fearing losses can sometimes cause you to hesitate when an opportunity presents itself, resulting in missed trades or entering at the wrong time. This happened to me after my big losses. I’d be scared to pull the trigger and watch the trades do what I thought they would do without me having a position.
Successful trading is about balancing risk and reward, and that balance is heavily influenced by your mindset. If you let emotions dictate your decisions then you may as well just cash out and head to the casino. You’re just as likely to lose.
Therefore, managing your psychology is just as important as managing your risk.
1. Develop a trading plan and stick to it
One of the easiest ways to take emotions out of trading is to have a well-structured trading plan. This is a pre-defined set of rules that govern how you will enter, manage, and exit trades. Your trading plan should cover the following elements:
- Entry criteria: What needs to happen in the market for you to initiate a trade? This could be based on technical indicators, chart patterns, or fundamental data.
- Exit criteria: When will you exit a trade? Define both your profit-taking target and stop-loss level before entering any position.
- Position sizing: How much of your capital are you willing to risk on any single trade? Sticking to this will prevent the emotional urge to chase bigger gains by risking more than you can afford.
When you have a plan and stick to it, you remove the emotional guesswork that often leads to bad decisions. Over time, following a disciplined process will not only make you more consistent but will also reinforce the habits needed for long-term success.
2. Learn to embrace losses
Nobody likes to lose money. I certainly don’t. But in trading, losses are inevitable. Even the most successful traders have losing trades (unless, of course, you’re an Instagram trader).
The difference between a novice and a professional is how they handle those losses. You need to be able to take a loss and not think about it. Roger Federer credits his ‘next point’ mentality as being a key factor in his success.
Every point would be the most important point in the world. But once it was won or lost – he was instantly able to move on and focus on the next one. Some have said Tiger Woods in golf has a similar mentality and level of focus.
One of the most damaging psychological traps is revenge trading. This is trying to make back the money you’ve lost by taking bigger and riskier trades on the same stock or another. This almost always results in greater losses.
To prevent this, you need to shift your mindset. Accept that losses are part of the game and that they provide valuable learning experiences. Every losing trade can be an opportunity to refine your strategy or improve your timing. Instead of letting a loss ruin your day, see it as part of the journey, log it in your trading journal, and review it. Over time, this mindset will build resilience and help you stay focused on the bigger picture.
3. Maintain a trading journal
Tracking your trades and keeping a detailed journal is one of the most powerful tools for improving your trading psychology. In your journal, you should record not only your trade details but also your thought process and emotions at the time of the trade. Did you feel anxious? Confident? Nervous?
Over time, patterns will emerge in your behaviour, showing you how your emotions are influencing your trades. For example, you might notice that after a big win, you tend to take riskier trades and give back your profits. Or perhaps after a few losses, you hesitate to enter good trades, fearing more losses. Once you identify these patterns, you can work on correcting them.
A trading journal also keeps you accountable. When you start tracking your emotions and decisions, you become more aware of how often your feelings dictate your actions. This awareness can lead to better discipline and improved decision-making over time.
4. Practice mindfulness and stress management
Trading is a high-stress activity, and that stress can cloud your judgment. Learning how to manage your stress levels is crucial for maintaining a sharp and focused mindset. One of the best ways to do this is through mindfulness practices such as meditation and deep breathing. I’m told that yoga is also great, but as you can see from my latest YouTube video, I’m not very good at it.
Mindfulness helps traders stay present and focused, reducing the tendency to ruminate on past mistakes or worry about future outcomes. By putting yourself in the present moment, you can make more rational decisions based on the current market conditions, rather than letting emotions from past trades affect your thinking.
Additionally, managing stress through regular exercise, sufficient sleep, and breaks from the screen can improve your mental clarity and decision-making abilities. Trading when you’re tired, stressed, or emotionally drained is a recipe for mistakes. If I have a night where I’ve not slept properly and feel tired, then I ban myself from trading.
Conclusion
The way you think and manage your emotions has a profound impact on your results in the market. By developing a solid trading plan, accepting losses, keeping a journal, and managing your stress through mindfulness, you can cultivate the mental edge needed to stay ahead in this challenging game. Remember, this is just a starting article. The onus is on you to go further and do your own research.
Remember, the market will always test your emotions. But by building mental resilience and sticking to a disciplined approach, you can keep those emotions in check.
Michael Taylor
Get Michael’s trade ideas: newsletter.buythebullmarket.com
Twitter: @shiftingshares
Got some thoughts on this week’s article from Michael? Share these in the SharePad chat. Login to SharePad – click on the chat icon in the top right – select or search for a specific share or the “Traders chat”
